THIRD EXAMINER · JOURNAL-SUBMISSION AUDIT
Shear bond strength of a bulk-fill resin composite to dentin using four adhesive protocols: an in-vitro study
REFERENCES
22 of 24 OK
AUTHOR RULES
3 of 10 ready
Does each reference support its sentence?
Every reference was read against the sentence that cites it, and its details checked against the DOI record.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
KEEP · 22WRONG CLAIM · 1FIX DETAILS · 1
[14]WRONG CLAIM
Cited for '10,000 thermocycles equal one year in the mouth'; the source reports a range and does not state this equivalence.
[22]FIX DETAILS
Year and volume do not match the DOI record.
[7]COPIED TEXT
Two Discussion sentences follow [7] without quotation marks. Journals run a similarity check on every submission.
Ready for the journal's author rules?
Generic rules common to dental journals. A named journal's rules are added only after we verify them on its author-guidelines page.
| STATUS | RULE | THIS MANUSCRIPT |
|---|---|---|
| MISSING | Consent for the use of extracted teeth | Not stated |
| MISSING | Conflict of interest and funding statements | Not stated |
| MISSING | Data availability statement | Not stated |
| MISSING | Reporting checklist for in-vitro studies (CRIS) | Not attached |
| FIX | Structured abstract | All four headings present; the conclusion repeats the unsupported claim (M1) |
| FIX | Numbered references, cited in order | In order; [14] and [22] need work |
| FIX | Tables cited in order, with units | Present; Table 4.2 needs the corrections listed later |
| READY | Keywords | Present |
| READY | Title page with affiliations and a corresponding author | Present |
| READY | Ethics approval statement | Present |
Reference verdicts, in full (all authors and titles are placeholders; journal: Placeholder Dental Journal)
| REF | REFERENCE AND NOTE | VERDICT |
|---|---|---|
| [1] | Example A, Sample B. Bond durability of resin composites to dentin. | KEEP |
| [2] | Placeholder C, Demo D. Universal adhesives: a narrative review. | KEEP |
| [3] | Example E, Sample F. Etch-and-rinse versus self-etch strategies. | KEEP |
| [4] | Placeholder G, Demo H. Bulk-fill composites: depth of cure. | KEEP |
| [5] | Example I, Sample J. Shear bond strength test methods. | KEEP |
| [6] | Placeholder K, Demo L. Specimen preparation for dentin bonding tests. | KEEP |
| [7] | Example M, Sample N. Smear layer and adhesive penetration. Supports its sentences; two of them copy its abstract without quotation marks. | KEEP |
| [8] | Placeholder O, Demo P. Hybrid layer formation. | KEEP |
| [9] | Example Q, Sample R. Phosphoric acid etching of dentin. | KEEP |
| [10] | Placeholder S, Demo T. Mild self-etch adhesives. | KEEP |
| [11] | Example U, Sample V. One-step adhesives and water sorption. | KEEP |
| [12] | Placeholder W, Demo X. Polymerisation shrinkage of bulk-fill materials. | KEEP |
| [13] | Example Y, Sample Z. Light-curing protocols. | KEEP |
| [14] | Placeholder A, Demo B. Thermocycling and simulated ageing. Cited for '10,000 thermocycles equal one year in the mouth'; the source reports a range and does not state this equivalence. | WRONG CLAIM |
| [15] | Example C, Sample D. Failure-mode analysis after debonding. | KEEP |
| [16] | Placeholder E, Demo F. Stereomicroscope evaluation of fracture surfaces. | KEEP |
| [17] | Example G, Sample H. Sample size in dental bond strength studies. | KEEP |
| [18] | Placeholder I, Demo J. Reporting in-vitro dental studies (CRIS). | KEEP |
| [19] | Example K, Sample L. Statistical analysis of bond strength data. | KEEP |
| [20] | Placeholder M, Demo N. Post-hoc comparisons in laboratory studies. | KEEP |
| [21] | Example O, Sample P. Extracted human teeth: storage and handling. | KEEP |
| [22] | Placeholder Q, Demo R. Universal adhesives in etch-and-rinse mode. Year and volume do not match the DOI record. | FIX DETAILS |
| [23] | Example S, Sample T. Clinical performance of universal adhesives. | KEEP |
| [24] | Placeholder U, Demo V. Dentin bonding: future directions. | KEEP |
Findings: must, should, optional
MUST
Rewrite the conclusion: C is comparable to the control (Tukey A vs C, p = 0.925), not above it.
MUST
Correct the group B mean from 12.58 to 15.28.
MUST
State n = 9 per group and report the exclusions.
MUST
Reword or replace the sentence cited to [14]: Cited for '10,000 thermocycles equal one year in the mouth'; the source reports a range and does not state this equivalence.
MUST
Add the consent, conflict-of-interest, funding and data-availability statements, and attach the CRIS checklist.
MUST
Quote or rewrite the two Discussion sentences that follow [7]. Journals run a similarity check on every submission.
SHOULD
Correct [22]: Year and volume do not match the DOI record.
SHOULD
Rewrite the two passages that read as machine-written (introduction, paragraph 1; discussion, paragraph 5).
SHOULD
Report the group D SD as 2.46 (0.82 is the SE).
SHOULD
Report the normality (lowest Shapiro–Wilk p = 0.395) and equal-variance (Levene p = 0.647) checks.
SHOULD
Add Tukey grouping letters to Table 4.2.
OPTIONAL
Show SD error bars on the bar chart of means.
OPTIONAL
Report the mean differences between groups with confidence intervals.
Checked and fine
OK
Thermocycling protocol (5,000 thermocycles) is described and matches the methods.
OK
One-way ANOVA recomputes exactly: F(3, 32) = 24.21, p < 0.001.
OK
Tukey post-hoc is the right follow-up for four independent groups.
OK
Means for groups A, C and D, and SDs for groups A, B and C, recompute from the raw data.
OK
Every other reference supports its sentence and matches its DOI record.