الممتحنالثالث
ما تستلمه

تدقيق البحث

بطاقة المحاور الثمانية، وما يمنع النشر، وخطة إصلاح خطوة بخطوة.

تقرير نموذجي. الرسالة وبياناتها وكل المراجع أدناه وهمية. التقرير يُكتب بلغة الرسالة. الرسالة النموذجية مكتوبة بالإنجليزية، لذلك التقرير أدناه بالإنجليزية.

THIRD EXAMINER · MANUSCRIPT AUDIT

Shear bond strength of a bulk-fill resin composite to dentin using four adhesive protocols: an in-vitro study

Manuscript prepared from an MSc thesis · fictional sample · Standard: CRIS · Ref. TE-0000
47 / 80 points
Major revision
Not ready to submit. Three findings block publication; each is fixable without new experiments.

Three things that block publication

1
C is not above the control: A 18.97 vs C 18.33 MPa, Tukey p = 0.925.
M1 · T04
2
Group B mean 12.58 MPa can't be computed from the raw data; the true mean is 15.28.
M2 · D02, H1
3
Methods say n = 10 per group; the data hold 9 (36 in total), with no exclusions reported.
M3 · INV-1

Scorecard

eight areas, each out of 10
Ethics
8
Approval and tooth source stated; donor consent wording missing.
References
7
[14] cited for a claim it doesn't make; [22] details don't match its DOI.
Language
7
Clear English; results overstate, two passages read machine-written.
Methods reporting
6
Specimen count misstated (10 vs 9); exclusions not reported.
Novelty
5
Well-studied comparison; the bulk-fill pairing adds a modest increment.
Statistics
5
Right tests; checks unreported, one SE given as an SD.
Data plausibility
5
Three of four group means recompute; group B does not.
Internal consistency
4
Headline claim contradicts its own table; n contradicts F(3, 32).
Total 47 / 80 = 59%, grade C.A = ready with light polish · F = not defensible as written

Reported vs recomputed: 13 numbers checked

Full table on page 2: every reported value beside the value recomputed from the raw sheets.
This review grades evidence, not people.Third Examiner · fictional sample · p. 1 of 3
THIRD EXAMINER · MANUSCRIPT AUDITC · 59%p. 2 of 3

Reported vs recomputed

QUANTITYREPORTEDRECOMPUTEDSTATUS
Specimens per group109MISMATCH
Mean, group A (MPa)18.9718.97MATCH
Mean, group B (MPa)12.5815.28MISMATCH
Mean, group C (MPa)18.3318.33MATCH
Mean, group D (MPa)11.0811.08MATCH
SD, group A (MPa)1.451.45MATCH
SD, group B (MPa)2.432.43MATCH
SD, group C (MPa)2.282.28MATCH
SD, group D (MPa)0.822.46MISMATCH
One-way ANOVAF(3, 32) = 24.21F = 24.21, p < 0.001MATCH
A vs C (Tukey)C significantly above Ap = 0.925, not significantMISMATCH
Normality (Shapiro–Wilk)Not reportedlowest p = 0.395ADD
Equal variances (Levene)Not reportedp = 0.647ADD

Scorecard: the reason behind each score

AREASCOREREASON
Ethics8 / 10Approval and the source of the teeth are stated. Donor consent wording is missing.
References7 / 10Most references support their sentences. [14] is cited for a claim it does not make; [22] has details that do not match its DOI record.
Language7 / 10Clear and mostly correct English. The results chapter states conclusions more strongly than the data allow, two passages read as machine-written, and two Discussion sentences follow [7] without quotation marks.
Methods reporting6 / 10Protocols and thermocycling are clear. The specimen count is misstated (10 vs 9) and exclusions are not reported, as CRIS requires.
Novelty5 / 10Comparing universal-adhesive modes with an etch-and-rinse control is well studied; pairing them with a bulk-fill composite adds a modest increment.
Statistics5 / 10The right test and post-hoc. Assumption checks are not reported, one SE is given as an SD, and the conclusion contradicts the Tukey result.
Data plausibility5 / 10Three of the four group means recompute exactly from the raw sheets; group B does not (12.58 typed, 15.28 true).
Internal consistency4 / 10The headline claim contradicts its own table, and the stated n contradicts both the sheets and the degrees of freedom, F(3, 32).
This review grades evidence, not people.Third Examiner · fictional sample · p. 2 of 3
THIRD EXAMINER · MANUSCRIPT AUDITC · 59%p. 3 of 3

Fix roadmap, in order

  1. 1
    Rewrite the conclusion and the abstract: C is comparable to the control, not superior.
    Author Tukey A vs C, p = 0.925; A has the higher mean.
  2. 2
    Correct the group B mean to 15.28 in Table 4.2, the text and the abstract.
    Author It is the mean of the raw data; the typed value cannot be reproduced.
  3. 3
    State n = 9 per group; list each excluded specimen and why.
    Author + supervisor CRIS asks for the sample size and every exclusion.
  4. 4
    Report the group D SD as 2.46.
    Author 0.82 is the standard error.
  5. 5
    Add the normality and equal-variance results to methods and results.
    Author Reviewers ask for them; both pass, so this only strengthens the paper.
  6. 6
    Reword the sentence cited to [14]; correct the details of [22].
    Author Each reference must support its sentence and match its DOI record.
  7. 7
    Quote or rewrite the two sentences that follow [7], and rewrite the two passages that read as machine-written.
    Author Journals run a similarity check on every submission.
  8. 8
    Read the results chapter against every table once more.
    Supervisor Two of the three blockers are mismatches between text and tables.
This review grades evidence, not people.Third Examiner · fictional sample · p. 3 of 3