THIRD EXAMINER · AUDIT TRAIL
Shear bond strength of a bulk-fill resin composite to dentin using four adhesive protocols: an in-vitro study
6
decisions, each with its reason
16 tests runevery test listed, passed or failed
7 PASS
9 FAIL
Decisions, in order
D01Grade against CRIS (in-vitro dental studies).Study type from the methods chapter
D02Group B's 12.58 is a transcription error; the true mean is 15.28.Recomputed from the raw sheet
D03Group D's 0.82 is a standard error reported as an SD.Recomputed SD and SE
D04Use n = 9 per group, not 10.Specimen inventory INV-1
D05Keep one-way ANOVA with Tukey; no switch to a non-parametric test.Assumption checks A01
D06Classify the headline claim as Critical (M1).Recomputed Tukey test T04
Tests
T01Raw data sheets present for every groupPASS
T09Assumption checks reported in the thesisFAIL
T02Specimens per group match the methodsFAIL
T10Post-hoc test fits the designPASS
T03Group means recompute from the raw dataFAIL
T11Reference [14] supports its sentenceFAIL
T04Headline claim "C above A" holds in TukeyFAIL
T12Reference [22] details match the DOI recordFAIL
T05SDs recompute from the raw dataFAIL
T13Thermocycling protocol reportedPASS
T06ANOVA recomputesPASS
T14Ethics approval statedPASS
T07Normality within each groupPASS
T15No copied sentence without quotation marksFAIL
T08Equal variances (Levene)PASS
T16Writing reads as the author's ownFAIL
Why each decision was made
| ID | WHY | CHECK |
|---|---|---|
| D01 | The study is a laboratory test on extracted teeth. | Study type from the methods chapter |
| D02 | The mean of the 9 raw values is 15.28; the typed value has the same digits in another order (H1). | Recomputed from the raw sheet |
| D03 | SD 2.46 divided by √9 gives 0.82. | Recomputed SD and SE |
| D04 | The sheets hold 9 per group, and F(3, 32) only fits 36 specimens. | Specimen inventory INV-1 |
| D05 | Normality (lowest Shapiro–Wilk p = 0.395) and equal variances (Levene p = 0.647) hold. | Assumption checks A01 |
| D06 | It is the thesis's main conclusion and the data contradict it: Tukey A vs C, p = 0.925. | Recomputed Tukey test T04 |
Test results
T014 of 4 groupsPASS
T02stated 10, found 9FAIL
T03A, C, D match; B 12.58 vs 15.28FAIL
T04Tukey A vs C, p = 0.925FAIL
T05D reported 0.82, true 2.46FAIL
T06F(3, 32) = 24.21, p < 0.001PASS
T07Shapiro–Wilk lowest p = 0.395PASS
T08p = 0.647PASS
T09not reportedFAIL
T10Tukey after one-way ANOVAPASS
T11wrong claimFAIL
T12year and volume differFAIL
T13stated in the methodsPASS
T14stated in the methodsPASS
T15two Discussion sentences follow [7]FAIL
T16two passages flagged, with reasonsFAIL
Other evidence IDs
| ID | WHAT IT RECORDS |
|---|---|
| INV-1 | Specimen inventory: 9 specimens per group on the raw sheets, 36 in total; no exclusion log. |
| H1 | Hypothesis for M2: 15.28 was typed as 12.58 (same digits, two swapped). Supported: the raw mean is 15.28, and the typed value reuses its digits. |
| A01 | Assumption checks run on the raw data. Shapiro–Wilk: A 0.538, B 0.682, C 0.395, D 0.830. Levene p = 0.647. |